E! News sits down with the lead actors of Starz’s Outlander (Season 2) and asks them to reveal spoilers for the new season. Watch Caitriona Balfe (Claire Fraser), Sam Heughan (Jamie Fraser), and Tobias Menzies (Frank/Jack Randall) get creative with what happens. Time travel or a giant squid. What seems more likely?

Watch the video above and see if you can spot the truths!